Advertising Is Dead. Long Live PR

Although I still believe there is a place for advertising as a brand maintenance or brand affirmation tool, I am convinced that to build a brand today, you need PR. At one time advertising did build brands. But this was in a simpler America. That America, sadly, is no more.

Ive been re-reading The Fall Of Advertising & The Rise Of PR, by Al and Laura Ries, and it is their book that has moved me from suspicion of advertisings demise as a brand-builder to conviction.

As the Ries say, Publicity is the nail, advertising is the hammer. What does this mean? It means that your PR effort helps make your message believable so that your advertising will have credibility when it hits.

Typically, companies want to hit the market hard and make a lot of noise. Advertising allows you to launch quickly, control the message, and have your message in as many media as you have the money for. However, that does not mean your message will be believed. The louder advertisers yell, the less likely I am to believe them. How about you?

PR takes time and does not necessarily work on your schedule. Planting new ideas or changing minds is a slow process. When your PR program rolls out over a longer period of time, prospects have time to adjust their attitudes. Brands that take this approach are longer lasting, too.

Chevrolet, for years the number one auto brand, was still number one in ad spending in 2001. It spent $819 million dollars 39 percent more than Ford spent. That year, Ford outsoldevrolet by 33 percent. Since 1997, Chevrolet has outspent and undersold Ford. Chevrolet spends $314 per vehicle and Ford spends $170 per vehicle. Do you think advertising is working for Chevrolet?

Kmart, embroiled in financial difficulty for years, had revenues of $37 billion and spent $542 million on US advertising in 2001. Wal-Mart spent $498 million and garnered four times the revenue: $159 billion split between its Wal-Mart and Sams Club stores. The average Wal-Mart store does $46 million in sales each year while its Sams Club average store sells $56 million. Sams Club does almost no advertising.

Those are old brands, youre saying. What about some newer brands, Harry?

OK, lets look at Pets.com. Remember the dog sock puppet that starred in their commercials? It won awards, but not sales. In six months Pets.com had $22 million in revenues and spent four times that much on advertising. Off-base advertising creativity at work.

The Body Shop was built totally by publicity. No advertising at all. Starbucks, until recently, did virtually no advertising. It has built a brand through good PR efforts. Starbucks annual sales are around $1.3 billion, while advertising expenditures over 10 years, have totaled less than $10 million.

Finally, what advertising agency do you know that has built its brand with ads? Things that make you go hmm.

Harry Hoover is a partner in My Creative Team. He has 30 years of experience in crafting and delivering bottom line messages that ensure success for serious businesses like Bank of Commerce, The Bray Law Firm, Brent Dees Financial Planning, CruisingTheICW.com, Duke Energy, Focus Four, Levolor, North Carolina Tourism, TeamHeidi, Ty Boyd Executive Learning Systems, VELUX, and Verbatim.

Take Your Radio Ads to the Next Level
Electronic Score Boards
Go Ahead Im Listening
Yellow Pages Ads - Buying Secrets
Advertising 101
How To Write Really Good Ads
Non-profit Coupon Books and Coupon Mailers for Small Businesses
How To Make Your Yellow Page Ads Work
4 Ways to Double the Power of Your Business Cards
Which is Better Digital or Offset Printing?
Why Not Use the Humble Fax in Your Advertising Strategy?
Whats On Your Business Card?
16 Ways to Make Your Business Cards Unforgettable
Seven Ways to Waste Your Money on Yellow Pages Advertising
Top 9 Reasons To Advertise
10 Ways To Improve Your Print Ads
Electronic Reader Board
The Skinny on Billboards
The Principle Of Advertising Online
Advertising Inserts
When Advertising Wears Out